Good Stewards vs myICLUB

The myICLUB alternative built for families.

myICLUB is the veteran of investment-club accounting — unit values, member ledgers, and club tax forms, trusted by traditional clubs for decades. But it keeps the books after you trade somewhere else. Good Stewards is where your family actually decides and invests: propose, vote, execute, one shared record — for half the price.

Good Stewards

Free

Unlimited family members, K-1s included, free for as long as you run the club yourself.

myICLUB

$160/year

renewal; federal & state tax printers sold separately ($98/year with a BetterInvesting club discount).

Side by side

Good StewardsmyICLUB

Built forFamilies building wealth togetherTraditional investment clubs

TradingPropose → vote → execute through the family’s brokerage accountNone — trade at your broker, then type it into the books

DecisionsMember voting and family rules built inHandled offline, outside the software

RecordsOne shared record — every holding, vote, and decisionPartnership accounting: unit values and member ledgers

TaxesClean records and exports for your tax preparerClub 1065/K-1 generation — sold as paid add-ons

PriceFree — unlimited members, K-1s included. $99/yr only for automatic contributions$160/year + tax printer add-ons

Grows intoMeetings, governance, and a full family office when you’re readyBookkeeping is the ceiling

Competitor pricing and features as published July 2026 — verify current details on their site.

Honest answer

When myICLUB is the right choice

Your club has decades of partnership accounting history it needs to keep intact, exactly as-is.

You’re a traditional club of unrelated members whose only need is unit-value bookkeeping and club tax filing.

Your treasurer loves the current workflow and nobody wants the club to do more than it does today.

If you want your family — not a club of strangers — deciding and investing together in one place, that’s the job Good Stewards was built for.

Founding families

Invest together. As a family.

Propose the trade. Vote as a family. Execute through a real brokerage account — one shared record everyone can see. Ten founding families, built five at a time.